Do the majority of Islamic scholars reject Hadiths?
And are you an Islamic Scholar?
scholar my arse
you are dismissed as a mushrik
cheers
I believe in Hadiths so therefore, I am a mushrik?
If so, then majority of the Islamic Scholars, if not all, are mushrik too?
You are not to contemplate your own opinion of Islam and express it as you don't clearly know Islam; you must be a Islamic Scholar. _________________
Do the majority of Islamic scholars reject Hadiths?
And are you an Islamic Scholar?
scholar my arse
you are dismissed as a mushrik
cheers
I believe in Hadiths so therefore, I am a mushrik?
If so, then majority of the Islamic Scholars, if not all, are mushrik too?
You are not to contemplate your own opinion of Islam and express it as you don't clearly know Islam; you must be a Islamic Scholar.
Again, stop acting stupid
Islam is not for your scholars, your scholars are nothing but a bunch of gangs who forbids and allow what Allah has not sanctioned
on the other hand mister smart, you will never be able to blame them if they are wrong, and most certainly they are wrong, look at the fruit of Islam as we see it after 1000 years of corruption, very fruitful hey
oh yeh, here is one of your scholars,
see if you look like a scholar, and talk like a scholar, then he must be a scholar, however this scholar that you are about to see, was fuking males in the MOSQUE where he was its Imam
You postulates some things about the prophet which you basicly don't know.
You don't know wether he asked people to write down and remember all the things he said and did, do you? I'm not argueing against the historical invalidity of the hadith. Your claim is just a bit to arrogant.
Cheers. _________________ Yes, we have a "soul"; but it's made of lots of tiny robots. - Daniel Dennet
You postulates some things about the prophet which you basicly don't know.
Hello
Yes I do know, it is you who don't know
did you read the 9 books of hadith complete in Arabic?
if no, then please sthu
Tvebak wrote:
You don't know wether he asked people to write down and remember all the things he said and did, do you? I'm not argueing against the historical invalidity of the hadith. Your claim is just a bit to arrogant.
Cheers.
of course he did, he ordered them not to write anything but the Quran, would you like to see the hearsay hadith from the 9 books of hadith? _________________ And say: Truth has arrived, and Falsehood perished: for Falsehood is bound to perish. [The Quran ; 17:81]
You postulates some things about the prophet which you basicly don't know.
Hello
Yes I do know, it is you who don't know
did you read the 9 books of hadith complete in Arabic?
if no, then please sthu
Tvebak wrote:
You don't know wether he asked people to write down and remember all the things he said and did, do you? I'm not argueing against the historical invalidity of the hadith. Your claim is just a bit to arrogant.
Cheers.
of course he did, he ordered them not to write anything but the Quran, would you like to see the hearsay hadith from the 9 books of hadith?
Hi Ahmed
Yes I would like to see it, then I would have another argument against those "followers of hadith", that would be fine. And no I haven't read the hadith. Not plannig to do in the near future.
Cheers _________________ Yes, we have a "soul"; but it's made of lots of tiny robots. - Daniel Dennet
You postulates some things about the prophet which you basicly don't know.
Hello
Yes I do know, it is you who don't know
did you read the 9 books of hadith complete in Arabic?
if no, then please sthu
Tvebak wrote:
You don't know wether he asked people to write down and remember all the things he said and did, do you? I'm not argueing against the historical invalidity of the hadith. Your claim is just a bit to arrogant.
Cheers.
of course he did, he ordered them not to write anything but the Quran, would you like to see the hearsay hadith from the 9 books of hadith?
Hi Ahmed
Yes I would like to see it, then I would have another argument against those "followers of hadith", that would be fine. And no I haven't read the hadith. Not plannig to do in the near future.
Cheers
Hello
So you have not read them and just pick and choose what suit your mind as a kafir?
well let me tell you, what they call hadith science has nothing to do with science, however it has everything to do with conjectures, hearsay, allegations, gosips, fabrications, etc etc
sure some of it may be true, we just can never know, even the ones that comply 100% with the quran, we will never know for certain if the allegation is true or not, so please do swollow that crap called hadith science, every time i hear Muslim boasting about it, it either makes me laugh or puke
now for the ahdiths from Musannad Ahmed Ibn Hanbal, you need to look at my article on thiis web site called "Tas-hih Al Bukhari" and you should see the hadith there taken from the offical hadith site of the Saudi government
cheers _________________ And say: Truth has arrived, and Falsehood perished: for Falsehood is bound to perish. [The Quran ; 17:81]
You postulates some things about the prophet which you basicly don't know.
Hello
Yes I do know, it is you who don't know
did you read the 9 books of hadith complete in Arabic?
if no, then please sthu
Tvebak wrote:
You don't know wether he asked people to write down and remember all the things he said and did, do you? I'm not argueing against the historical invalidity of the hadith. Your claim is just a bit to arrogant.
Cheers.
of course he did, he ordered them not to write anything but the Quran, would you like to see the hearsay hadith from the 9 books of hadith?
Hi Ahmed
Yes I would like to see it, then I would have another argument against those "followers of hadith", that would be fine. And no I haven't read the hadith. Not plannig to do in the near future.
Cheers
Hello
So you have not read them and just pick and choose what suit your mind as a kafir?
well let me tell you, what they call hadith science has nothing to do with science, however it has everything to do with conjectures, hearsay, allegations, gosips, fabrications, etc etc
sure some of it may be true, we just can never know, even the ones that comply 100% with the quran, we will never know for certain if the allegation is true or not, so please do swollow that crap called hadith science, every time i hear Muslim boasting about it, it either makes me laugh or puke
now for the ahdiths from Musannad Ahmed Ibn Hanbal, you need to look at my article on thiis web site called "Tas-hih Al Bukhari" and you should see the hadith there taken from the offical hadith site of the Saudi government
cheers
Hi Ahmed
No I only stick to the quran. Maybe I will get around to read them at some time for historical reasons. As for debating those believing in the hadith I've only picked a few up as examples, some who does not contradict the quran, but contradict other circumstances. I haven't pick and choose what suit my mind. I haven't collected the damn hadith
Quote:
well let me tell you, what they call hadith science has nothing to do with science, however it has everything to do with conjectures, hearsay, allegations, gosips, fabrications, etc etc
I cannot disagree with this
I will have a look at your thread, thank you.
Cheers
_________________ Yes, we have a "soul"; but it's made of lots of tiny robots. - Daniel Dennet
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
FAQ 
Search 
Memberlist 
Usergroups 
Join! (free)
Profile 
Log in to check your private messages 
Log in
