Archive for FREE FAITH, EXPRESSION AND THOUGHT BREAK THE CHAINS OF IGNORANCE AND FEAR
 


       FREE FAITH, EXPRESSION AND THOUGHT Forum Index -> The Qur'an
ibnishaq

compilation of the qu'ran

hopefully no one will get off topic and start talking about christianity and such here!

ok so on faith freedom i posted a topic about compilation of qu'ran. i thought i would ask such here too so that i can get a response from all brains who i think is really smart! and baal too and other ex muslims/ or those who know about islam

so how you guys think quran was compiled? do you accept the traditional islamic view like FE peters or some other view? i would appreciate all input!
brainout

That's a good topic, ibnishaq. And I'm glad you asked for Muslims to respond. Will look forward to seeing the answers from them, as I'm curious, too. But why not give your answer, first? Smile
ibnishaq

i accept the traditional view because there is a lot of evidence for it such as the dome of rock etc.

FE peters is a prominent non muslim islamic scholar. probably the most respected and most knowledgeable one. and he accepts the traditional view, stating there is no evidence that goes against it.

vast majority of orientalists agree with the muslim view of the compilation of the qu'ran
ibnishaq

all brains - you know a lot.. so come give us your thought!
All_Brains

ibnishaq wrote:
all brains - you know a lot.. so come give us your thought!


Sure thing my friend.

I am just about to leave now and will be on this "addictive" thing later on today.

Hope you having a nice weekend! Smile
ibnishaq

ok thanks!

and yes my weekend is great. christmas sales all over so everything is so cheap!!
All_Brains

ibnishaq wrote:
ok thanks!

and yes my weekend is great. christmas sales all over so everything is so cheap!!


Then you may want to leave the PC for a while and have wander in the fresh air and do some shopping.

This thing can be full on and we should also have a normal life, while searching for the or "a" truth!

I am on my way now to do some shopping myself! Wink

       FREE FAITH, EXPRESSION AND THOUGHT Forum Index -> The Qur'an
Page 1 of 1
Create your own free forum | Buy a domain to use with your forum
Home|Home|Home|Home|HomeHome|Home|Home|Home|Home